Re: [vox] [ot] Enterprise?
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: [vox] [ot] Enterprise?
On Thu, 27 Sep 2001, Peter Jay Salzman wrote:
> if you could somehow add up the quality of the first episodes of stng, stds9
> and stv, it wouldn't equal the quality of the ste premier.
>
> all the other premiers, the characters were stiff, actors were uncomfortable
> in their roles, and it was obvious the writers didn't have much direction.
> frankly, the premier of stng was an embarrasment. the premier of stv was
> painful. the premier of stds9 was ... was ... unmemorable. i'll bet most
> people here can't even remember the first episode of ds9.
I agree. The pilot is a tough episode to base the show on.
However, I think as far the the special effect go, it was great. Even faced
with the tough position of being before TOS.
>
> somebody did their homework with ste. the actors seemed OK with their roles.
> the plot was extremely novel. i enjoyed learning about the relationship
> between vulcans and humans after first contact. it was exciting and uhhh...
> stimulating. :)
I think they didn't introduce the characters very well. I had a hard time
telling who was who in the beginning.
>
> the weakest part of the show was t'pau (is that the same t'pau that we see in
> sttos episode 'amok time'? i think they overdid her character a little.
> but it was forgivable considering how great the show was.
>
To nitpick: T'pol. :)
> considering how st series tend to start bad and get really, really good,
> this show has ALOT of potential.
>
> this show is a keeper. just as long as they change the opening song.
>
Yep. What were they thinking?
-Gabe
|
